How to Manage Different Investment Risk Tolerances Between Spouses

iStock 000020582407XSmall How to Manage Different Investment Risk Tolerances Between SpousesAfter 40+ years of marriage, my spouse and I have come to acknowledge that one of us is more of a financial risk taker than the other. Understanding this fact helps us live with each other’s opinions on how and in what we should invest. Here are some suggestions to help you do the same.

Understand each partner’s money history and experience.

You may not even be aware that you each have different perspectives on what risk is or how much to take when you invest.

In Silver Spoon Kids – How Successful Parents Raise Responsible Children by Eileen Gallo, P.H.D. And Jon Gallo, J.D, the authors suggest a couple of ways of identifying this. One is for each person to separately create their own money story by thinking about things such as:

  • 2 of your earliest money memories
  • what you learned your mother and father about money
  • family stories about money
  • what did you liked and disliked about how your mom or dad handled money
  • what kind of emotional issues you have with money and what kind of financial education you received.

 

Then tell each other your stories.

The other is to find out what your ‘money personality’ is by rating your money use, acquisition and management tenancies as one of three states:

  • Acquisition: Avoidant Secure Insatiable
  • Use: Miser Secure Compulsive overspender
  • Management: Micromanager Secure Chaotic

 

The book also provides a quiz to help you reflect on your tendencies in the above areas.

Know the effect of taking too much risk on yourself and your partner.

Taking on debt never has bothered me, because I have always felt that we kept it under control and no matter what, would pay it off. Years into my marriage, I found that for my spouse, it was truly disturbing, stressful and sleep depriving. Taking on a new mortgage is something so abhorrent to him that he absolutely refuses to do it. He pays off his credit card BEFORE the statement comes!

Knowing that we have different levels of stress around risk helps us pause and think through what we are doing – so that we don’t cause undue consternation.

Find your risk tolerance.

Maybe you haven’t a clue what your risk tolerance is. Here is a quiz that might help. It was developed by two university personal finance professors one at Virginia Tech and the other at Kansas State University.

Remember to consider real numbers. When you have low income, little savings, not much time to accumulate or lots of debt, you probably don’t want to be investing at high risk levels, according to Invesco.

Set your financial goals.

In order to meet some financial goals, you must take some level of risk. Nothing in life is certain. However, unless you agree on what your financial goals are as a couple, chances are you won’t get there. Once you agree on goals, and you both understand the need for both safety and risk to reach them, it should be easier for you to agree on investing allocations and strategies. This may be especially true if you divide up the pot and let the risk taker do the risky investments and the more conservative person handle the conservative investments.

Have some separate accounts.

You probably each have your own retirement accounts. Each person can manage them according to their own tolerance for risk and stage of life. In addition, you could handle the money and investing by splitting the invest-able amount between the two of you, each handling a portion of it.  We have done both.  I manage my own retirement accounts.  He manages the bond investments and I handle the stock, real estate and other investments.

Keep track at the household level.

In order for the separate account method to work, however, you need to track progress towards goals at the couple or household level – to make sure you are balanced overall. Consumer reports summarizes that in this comment:

 In the end, if one spouse invests aggressively while the other is more moderate or conservative, that’s OK, says Dawn Brown, a financial planner in New York City. You just have to look at your entire portfolio to make sure it’s allocated for your long-term goals.

Seek help.

The Association for Financial Counseling Planning and Education published a study by John E. Gilliam, Joseph W. Goetz, and Vickie L. Hampton which suggests that:

Financial planners have negotiated conflicting risk tolerances of spouses in various ways including implementing separate portfolios for each spouse, taking an average or weighted average of each spouse’s tolerance for risk, or simply basing portfolio allocation decisions on the spouse with the lowest risk tolerance.

Sometimes just having to organize your thoughts to present to a third party can make it easier to work out differences.

How do you and your spouse work out your investing differences and tolerate each other’s risk tolerances?


Comments

How to Manage Different Investment Risk Tolerances Between Spouses — 9 Comments

  1. Good article. I found it interesting as I am in the middle of a behavioral finance class right now for my masters program. You touch on some good points here, especially when having to consider another person.

  2. My wife is ultra-conservative, while I’m more open to taking risks. She manages the household finances and I manage both our retirement accounts.

    But what I did was set up her IRAs with conservative, dividend paying stocks, while mine have the riskier stocks. Even though in the end it all is one pool, she feels comfortable that her risk preference is incorporated into our overall investment allocations. Especially when her funds do better than mine :)

  3. Being honest about each other’s weaknesses when it comes to money will really help. It pays to take risk, but it’s also better to ensure that you’re not risking it all, so having separate accounts is one thing every couple should implement when it come to their finances.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

I appreciate your readership and really enjoy hearing your thoughts on different topics. Thank you for contributing to the discussion.